West Texas, Boston and a Made-For-TV Manhunt

While news media descended on Boston and in particular the suburb of Watertown the residents of West Texas, a small town located just north of Waco, TX, were tasked with sifting through the remains of their town after it had been virtually leveled in a blast at a fertilizer plant on Wednesday. Friday, NBC News reported that 60 residents remain unaccounted for, in addition to the 12 who had been killed. The clip above, filmed by a man who witnessed the blast inside a vehicle with a child (possibly his daughter), graphically shows the devastating power of the blast.

At the risk of appearing insensitive, let’s compare the West Texas tragedy with the Boston Marathon bombings. According to The Washington Post, the bombings ultimately killed four (including an MIT police officer who was reportedly killed by one of the suspects) and injured 176. At worst, the blast in West Texas may have killed 72 in addition to the 200 that NBC News reported had been injured. Yet, the news media––in particular the broadcast TV and cable TV news media––engaged in nonstop broadcasting of developments in the Boston Marathon bombings, while the events in West Texas were relegated to second or third tier status.

Why the disproportionate level of reporting? Could it be the drama of the seemingly made-for-TV manhunt? Could it be that no one would be interested in learning about a terrible blast at a fertilizer plant? Given the weight of the coverage, the answer seems clear: Broadcast and cable networks were seemingly convinced that we’d rather see endless minutes of reporting on what was getting to be a lengthy manhunt, more than we would be interested in seeing how residents of a small Texas town were dealing with a terrible tragedy of their own.

Maybe it’s because the Boston story took place in, well, Boston––a populous city on the eastern seaboard that became the site of a bombing that seemed to take place before our very eyes; that killed three individuals whose lives we came to know; that appeared to involve heroes masquerading as passersby. Maybe it’s because the blast in Texas took place in––Texas. And not only in Texas, but in a small town in the west of Texas; at a dusty, dirty fertilizer plant; that killed people who we didn’t see or come to know; that didn’t appear to involve readily identifiable, passionate “heroes.”

There are, of course, good reasons that the incident in Boston should have received significant media coverage––the incident’s terrorist implications seemed to dictate it. At the same time, however, we should wonder why a small town in Texas that suffered its own terrible tragedy was nearly forgotten by the media in all the news coming out of Boston. We should ask: What are the ethics of reporting a high-profile tragedy, and making it a primary focus of all news coverage? How does coverage (or lack thereof) imply that one story is more important than another? While there are no easy answers to these questions, we should at least pause and take a moment to reflect on them.

Many thanks to Teka Bundy for sharing the video with me.

Sources: washingtonpost.com, nbcnews.com, youtube.com

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “West Texas, Boston and a Made-For-TV Manhunt

  1. Brock says:

    LOL… sounds like something I’d say… only more eloquently stated! I would probably have used words like ‘sensationalist scum journalists’ etc… which doesn’t always sit well with the typical reader. 😉

    Is it any wonder I’m stuck to get my news from Jon Stewart… and to some extend, Stephen Colbert…? Because they happily state the truth about the ‘facts’ being reported! it isn’t just politicians that live by the adage ‘Never underestimate the stupidity of the masses’… less scrupulous journalists do too.

  2. Jeffrey Maciejewski says:

    Thanks Brock. I’m a huge fan of Stewart and Colbert too. I wanted to somehow put segments of theirs into the posts, but couldn’t get the snippets I wanted.

  3. Excellent article. Both were horrific acts and I feel awful for all victims involved. One received nonstop coverage for an entire week, and you can barely find an article about the other one on major news websites. I don’t blame the people of Boston to celebrate because that was a wonderful thing to catch the last bomber, but imagine being the victims’ families in Texas watching that unfold.

  4. Jeffrey Maciejewski says:

    Well said. On Twitter on Friday, I saw a tweet from someone attending a conference in Texas who said that many people down there were upset over the lack of media coverage–I can certainly see why. Like you said, Boston should celebrate–but we shouldn’t forget about what happened in Texas. Even now, when the media are still busy dissecting what happened in Boston, coverage of West Texas is practically nil.

Please share your thoughts …

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s